It’s a strong argument and good distinction. I would only wish that Muslim authors used another historical resource—Egypt’s lived experience at the very moment of Israel’s annexation of Palestine—because that is one of the most solid arguments we have of the non-persecuting ends of Islamic expansion. Not seeing Egypt today is not seeing the work Egypt’s people have done for centuries to protect non-Muslim populations. Human rights, indeed, and an Islamic cultural memory we need to learn from.
Excellent, excellent!
Not sure how this post found its way to me but so grateful.
It’s a strong argument and good distinction. I would only wish that Muslim authors used another historical resource—Egypt’s lived experience at the very moment of Israel’s annexation of Palestine—because that is one of the most solid arguments we have of the non-persecuting ends of Islamic expansion. Not seeing Egypt today is not seeing the work Egypt’s people have done for centuries to protect non-Muslim populations. Human rights, indeed, and an Islamic cultural memory we need to learn from.
Egypt is much neglected.
Very thorough!